Application of CMSY to reanalyze longest time series of catches and largest fishery collapse in history

Results of using CMSY, advanced yet easy to use fish stock assessment model developed at GEOMAR by Froese et al., to reanalyze more than five centuries of cod fishing in Eastern Canada suggests that annual yields could have been sustained at high levels if authorities had allowed the stock of northern Atlantic cod off Newfoundland and Labrador to recover in the 1980s.

A new study by a team of researchers from the Sea Around Us initiative at the University of British Columbia, the GEOMAR Helmholtz Centre for Ocean Research and Dalhousie University modelled the cod population trajectory for the entire period from 1508 to 2019. While the earlier fishery, which used lines and later traps, was sustainable and generated catches of 100,000 to 200,000 tons per year for 400 years, the unleashing of bottom trawlers onto Northern cod in the 1960s reduced their biomass to levels that could not sustain high catches.

“Our assessment suggests that the biomass —the weight of the population in the water— of northern cod is currently around 2% of what it was earlier,” said Rebecca Schijns, lead author of the study and a researcher with the Sea Around Us at UBC’s Institute for the Oceans and Fisheries.

“The interesting thing is that we got to these results by applying a computer-intensive but very simple stock assessment methods known as CMSY to catch data for five centuries. Different from previous assessments that required large amounts of information, this method basically requires only a time series of annual catches,” Schijns said. “The other information that is required is available from the scientific literature, and from people with knowledge of the fishery.”

Working with such a long time series allowed the researchers to reliably estimate maximum sustainable yield – the highest catch that a fish stock can support in the long-term, given that environmental conditions remain more or less constant– for northern cod at 380,000 tons per year.  

But such high catches are now only a dream.  Following a massive 810,000-ton catch taken mostly by foreign vessels in 1968, catches started declining. Moreover, once Canada declared a fishery exclusion zone in 1977, fishing was not halted to allow the stock to rebuild. Rather, a new, heavily subsidized local trawler fleet was let loose on the depleted stock. This led to a final collapse of the fishery, which still remained open to small-scale fishers even during the moratorium that was imposed in 1992. Moreover, in recent years, every time Northern cod appear to increase, the fishing quota was raised.

“As a student, I was on board of a German trawler of fishing off Newfoundland and Labrador in 1973 and I have vivid memories of this cod rush,” said Daniel Pauly, co-author of the study and the Sea Around Us Principal Investigator. “If artisanal fishers in the outports had been listened to when they warned about running out of cod to catch, things would be different now. The scientists then monitoring the cod stock ignored small-scale fishers and relied only on the data from trawlers which, however, did not reflect the cod stock’s decline because the trawlers could follow the cod further out than the small-scale fishers.”

Paying attention to what local and/or indigenous fishers have to say and integrating centuries-old catch data into stock assessments help better understand the total impact of fisheries on marine ecosystems and provide clues on how to effectively manage marine populations for the long term.

“The CMSY method proved to be useful in assessing the data-rich cod stock, but it also works with stocks for which we only have catch data. This method is able to provide more reliable estimates of stock status by incorporating past data-limited periods,” Pauly said. 

The CMSY method, thus, offers researchers, fisheries managers and policymakers the possibility of taking a comprehensive look into the status of the world’s most important fish stocks.

📷 Derek Keats, Wikimedia Commons

“While the collapse-without-recovery of this fishery is a textbook example of failed management, the obvious lessons (take out less than is regrown, let fish spawn before capture, provide refuges, stop fishing completely to allow recovery, act on early warning signs) have not been learned and instead identical mismanagement (severe overfishing, capture of juveniles, no refuges, no stop of fishing, ignoring all warnings) has led to the eradication of cod in the German Bight, the collapse of cod in the central Baltic, and the currently happening collapse of cod in the western Baltic at our doorstep,” explained Rainer Froese, lead creator of CMSY and co-author of the study. “Similar to the Newfoundland case, climate/environmental conditions are blamed for the collapses when instead the applied management would have collapsed the stocks in any case, with and without climate [change].” 

“Ancient catch data exist for several stocks, such as Bluefin tuna in the Mediterranean, which started being commercialized around the 8th century; Atlantic herring in the Baltic Sea, whose fishery started in the 13th century, and Atlantic salmon in the Celtic Sea, whose fishery started in the 14th century,” Jeffrey Hutchings, co-author of the study and a researcher at Dalhousie University, said. “There is a real opportunity to use these data to design policies that prevent collapses similar to that of the cod stock.”

Unanimously, the authors conclude that by integrating historical data into stock assessments, better understanding of the total impact of fisheries on marine ecosystems can be attained in order to effectively manage marine populations for a long-term future.

The paper “Five centuries of cod catches in Eastern Canada” was published in the ICES Journal of Marine Science, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/icesjms/fsab153

About Joann Glorioso

Events Coordinator / Communications & Public Relations Officer

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *